‘Written on Water’ Is a Handbook for Surviving Historical past


It’s unnerving to know you’re residing in historical past. Prior to now decade, as phrases I’d first encountered in books erupted into my each day lexicon—phrases like fascism, world pandemic, and ecological catastrophe—then settled, with alarming velocity, into the static of how issues are, I’ve usually felt dizzy and unsure of methods to stay. I’ve felt, as the author Eileen Chang as soon as wrote, like my on a regular basis life “is somewhat out of order, out of order to a terrifying diploma.”

Generally I’ve consoled myself with what feels just like the exceptionalism of our current instability. Has the tempo of change—social, political, ecological, technological—ever moved with such hallucinatory, harmful depth? However this comfort doesn’t attain the extra pressing query: Whereas I’m being hurled into the scary future, what am I speculated to do about breakfast, and vacuuming, and laundry? After I really feel caught like this, between the tidal tug of the occasions and the calls of my small however urgent life, studying a author like Chang is what brings me true consolation.

Zhang Ailing, also called Eileen Chang, turned a literary wunderkind in her native Shanghai for her fashionable and slyly observant tales of metropolis amorous affairs and romances—“a number of the trivial issues that occur between women and men,” as she put it, with attribute understatement—earlier than falling into obscurity after the 1949 Revolution, when she and her work had been now not welcome in mainland China. She was later rediscovered by Taiwanese and Hong Kong readers.

The info of her historic period serve a wholesome dose of humility to my very own sense of up to date tumult: As Chang was coming of age, competing warlords had been nonetheless trampling the grave of the Qing dynasty. China was combating the invading Japanese whereas additionally embroiled in a civil battle. Mao’s Communist rebels had been marching steadily within the provinces, getting ready to overturn all the things. Elsewhere, World Battle II was raging. All of this historic noise sparkles within the background of Chang’s writing—and in case you look intently, informs its very core—however someway, her eye stays determinedly educated on the person human life, catching and inspecting these fluttering bits of actuality that the tides of historical past threaten to scrub away. A brand new version of her early essays, Written on Water, translated by Andrew F. Jones (and edited by Jones and Nicole Huang), captures Chang’s irreverent voice and her cussed on a regular basis sensibility. This sensibility, powered by a modest humanism and fashioned by a delicate and heartbreaking self-discipline, has develop into my handbook for surviving historical past.

In 1944, when Written on Water was first revealed, Shanghai was a metropolis of commerce and vogue and unwilling political entanglement. China’s most cosmopolitan metropolis as a result of it was chopped up for international concessions after the primary Opium Battle, Shanghai to at the present time has a fame for “imply” and savvy individuals who know “methods to fish in troubled waters,” as Chang wrote. Like many Shanghainese, Chang herself was a “conventional Chinese language [person] tempered by the excessive strain of contemporary life,” one among many “misshapen merchandise” of a spot the place so many ideologies, cultures, and developments met and clashed and melded.

Her life, too, was misshapen by the wild instability of her time. In “Whispers,” Chang divulges that her father, as soon as a popular aristocrat within the Qing dynasty courtroom, was an opium addict who dominated dictatorially over his spouse, concubines, and kids. As soon as, he punished Chang by locking her in a room for months, refusing her medical remedy even when she received dysentery; solely with the assistance of a servant did she escape that room, and that family, one “chilly bitter” night time. Her mom, a bourgeois lady who most popular all issues European, left Chang together with her father for years at a time whereas she traveled. Later, when Chang was a scholar on the College of Hong Kong, the arrival of Japanese bombers minimize her research brief, forcing her to return to Shanghai. She was solely in Hong Kong in any respect as a result of the world battle had made college in London an impossibility.

However what’s captured in these essays shouldn’t be Chang’s life a lot as her way of life and seeing. These are dashes of vivid statement, sketches of no matter Chang occurs to wish to write about: motion pictures, cash, her buddies’ favourite sayings. Take “On Carrots,” a two-paragraph transcription of a reminiscence her aunt as soon as recounted over a meal of turnip soup, about Granny feeding carrots to the pet cricket, which Chang thought a “fashionable little essay.” Or “Below an Umbrella,” a bite-size riff on a wet day that doubles as a parable about class. “Those that don’t have an umbrella press in opposition to those that do, squeezing beneath the perimeters of passing umbrellas to keep away from the rain,” she writes. “However the water cascading from the umbrellas seems to be worse than the rain itself and the folks squeezed between umbrellas are soaked to the pores and skin.” Her crisp ethical? “When poor people affiliate with the wealthy, they often get soaked.”

Then there’s the structurally fascinating “Epilogue: Days and Nights of China,” which follows the author step-by-step on a stroll to the vegetable market. Chang describes in fastidious element the attention-grabbing folks she passes on her method, as if transcribing one of many energetic character drawings interspersed all through the guide (“a tangerine vendor,” “a Taoist monk,” “a servant lady”). Then she goes residence, writes a poem, and the essay—and the guide—ends.


Written on Water evokes a lyric Chinese language conception of ephemerality whereas additionally alluding to Keats (his headstone reads “Whose title was writ in water”). As Huang writes in an afterword, the title got here to Chang in English first. However for me, it may’t seize the barbed playfulness of the Chinese language, 流言 (Liu Yan), which interprets to “flowing phrases” but in addition means “gossip.” Certainly, Chang relished any event to take a “stealthy look at each other’s personal lives.” She declared, “The secrets and techniques of on a regular basis life have to be made public at the least every year.” She thought literature ought to “plainly sing in reward of the placid.” She most popular the “noise and clatter” of metropolis streets to “rousing” symphonies. She wished historians would write extra about “irrelevant trivia.”

With this assertion, she opens “From the Ashes,” her account of the Battle of Hong Kong, Japan’s December 1941 assault on the then–British colony. Within the essay, Chang recollects surviving weeks of shelling and unhappily volunteering as a makeshift nurse. However what she foregrounds is a string of virtually devastatingly flippant observations: the “rich abroad Chinese language” dorm mate who’d packed garments for dances and dinner events however didn’t know what to put on for a battle; “hardy” Evelyn who stuffed herself with extra rice than ever whereas rations ran out, after which received constipated; defiant Yanying—“the one one among my classmates who had any guts”—who left the basement to take a shower, singing whilst a stray bullet shattered the window. These anecdotes are instructed with amusement and a few light mocking, but in addition with admiration: Listed below are individuals who, in a literal battle zone, insisted on the small pleasures of residing.

Chang defended her trivial tales in opposition to those that would possibly want them extra heroic. Bizarre folks going about their lives, falling in love, and appearing on petty fancies may not make a “monument to an period,” however, she wrote, “individuals are extra easy and unguarded in love than they’re in battle or revolution.” Chang had no need to write down about “supermen,” who “are born of particular epochs.” Why, when the “everlasting”—the grist of each day life that’s the solely true stability—was proper there? She understood the contradiction in her perception: that though on a regular basis life is basically “precarious,” “topic at common intervals to destruction,” it’s also the fabric from which springs the really human, and the divine. (Additionally: “Chest-pounding, wildly gesticulating heroes are annoying.”)

I learn in Chang’s decided apolitical gaze a transgressive, female ethos. For quite a lot of historical past—and nonetheless, amazingly, as we speak—males have formed epochs, with their empires and conquests. In the meantime, girls have sustained the fact that’s accrued in days: going to the market, mending clothes, cooking and cleansing, carrying and caring for the people who find themselves coming subsequent. In “A Chronicle of Altering Garments,” Chang paperwork the passing vogue fads—collars rising then disappearing, necklines going from sq. to spherical to heart-shaped—as “warlords got here and went.” Chang cherished garments and designed a lot of her personal. Trend is decidedly trivial, and Chang’s curiosity in it’s a highly effective facet of her “misshapen” morality, a technique of insisting on one thing minorly significant in a world of regularly shifting values. Buffeted from place to put by battle, Chang may management little of her exterior circumstances, however she may resolve, day by day, what to put on.

“Every of us lives inside our personal garments,” she writes. We stay inside our garments; we stay inside our days. Imagined as a container for all times itself, the vanities of vogue acquire pressing ethical significance. On this mild, the dullness of menswear could be seen as a type of depravity: “If males had been extra thinking about clothes,” Chang writes, they may be “a bit much less inclined to make use of numerous schemes and stratagems to draw the eye and admiration of society and sacrifice the well-being of the nation and the folks within the technique of securing their very own status.” Consider the uniforms of males like Steve Jobs or Mao Zedong, who most popular to protect the power it took to decorate for undertaking what Chang known as “earth-shattering deeds.” Chang was already well-known when she revealed this guide, however she distances her writing from this epic realm, evaluating herself as an alternative to a toddler operating residence from faculty, desirous to gab about all the things she’s seen to any out there grownup.

Can seeing be an ethic, a method we select to stay? For Chang, it was additionally a approach to proceed residing. To repair a gaze can be to search out one thing—something—to carry on to amid terror and chaos. In “Seeing With the Streets,” Chang teaches us methods to see the fact that may be irrevocably disrupted by historical past. She walks by means of town, observing the shows of store home windows, passing by means of the smoke and smells of road distributors, and noticing the same old folks and issues, earlier than a army blockade brings her stroll and day to a halt. On a regular basis life is everlasting; in battle, the everlasting is in grave hazard.

Behind Chang’s understanding irony, I hear a determined urgency. I hear the rapt consideration of somebody who loves her world and sees that it’s disappearing. I hear: What you treasure, nevertheless foolish, may not be right here tomorrow. Chang wrote just like the satan was chasing her. It’s as if she knew that when the period she lived in reached its fruits, there would possibly now not be a spot for somebody like her—a author between nations, epochs, and ideologies—“within the barren wastes of the longer term.” “Hurry! Hurry!” she wrote. Hurry to seize actuality, as intently as doable; hurry, maintain on to it and maintain it. Then you definately may need it for tomorrow, to show over in your hand, for just a bit pleasure, somewhat amusement, somewhat chuckle, even after it’s now not actual.


​Once you purchase a guide utilizing a hyperlink on this web page, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.



Supply hyperlink

Stay in Touch

To follow the best weight loss journeys, success stories and inspirational interviews with the industry's top coaches and specialists. Start changing your life today!

Related Articles